Many libraries are reconsidering their abstract&index database subscriptions in light of multidisciplinary tools like Google Scholar and customized discovery services. Others may be considering new index purchases and wondering if they're worth the money. This presentation will demonstrate how UPEI uses Google Sheets and student workers to create useful comparison lists for collection decision making. Featured will be comparisons done on PAIS, Philosopher's Index, Historical Abstracts, and ASFA (Aquatic Sciences and Fisheries Abstracts) for cancellation consideration, and on women's studies and mechatronics engineering for consideration of new products. Emphasis will be placed on method and customization of results for your institution's needs. Some advanced spreadsheet tricks that also apply to Excel will be included.